Firstpost. Wednesday, October 15, 2014 | Latest E-book | Subscribe to Newsletter 
15trending
Articles
Check this out: Mars Orbiter sends its first video from the Red Planet 
Maharashtra Assembly polls: A BJP win will mark electoral demise of 'marathi manoos' 
When Farah Khan yelled at Vivaan Shah (Movie Snippets) 
Assembly elections live: Haryana, Maharashtra vote; will Modi magic work? 
Mr Foreign Hand: Kailash Satyarthi now gets bashed for Nobel Peace Prize 
Who is a true Shah Rukh Khan fan? A German shows India 
Rs 12 per ticket is cost of an independent airline regulator 
Boney Kapoor slaps 'Sridevi' with legal notice: Well played Ram Gopal Varma! 
As Maharashtra votes today, Shiv Sena says it's confident of forming govt 
Revival on cards, here are 5 questions that Rahul must ask Cong seniors 
Stage set for high-stake fight as Haryana, Maharashtra go to polls Rs.1,000 crore package for cyclone-hit Andhra Heavy rains kill 18 in Uttar Pradesh 
ISL Match 3 as it happened: Delhi Dynamos held to a 0-0 draw by FC Pune City 
ISL: Del Piero, Dynamos fail to break Pune goalkeeper Belardi's resilience You are here: Latest News › Blogs Close(x) 
Mihir FadnavisMihir Fadnavis is a film critic and certified movie geek who has consumed more movies than meals. He blogs at http://mihirfadnavis.blogspot.in. Read Bio Mihir Fadnavis Get Alerts from this author Follow this author on Twitter View all posts from this authorWhat If review: Daniel Radcliffe and Zoe Kazan can't save this boring rom-com Tweet Tweet Facebook Share Facebook Share Google + Share 0 Google + Share 0 Email Print this Articlealso see
Haider review Shahid, Tabu mesmerise in Vishal Bhardwaj's best so far
Bang Bang! review The remake is even more stupid than the original
Bang Bang! review Hrithik, Katrina show how explosively dumb Bollywood can be
Ekkees Toppon Ki Salaami review A promising storyline that ends up as Facepalmrelated videos
Life after Harry Potter The reality is gradually sinking in
Harry Potter fans bid emotional farewell to boy wizardSPONSORED POST 
#MarkOfProfessionalism: Commitment to Excellence
eDITORS' pICKS
In praise of Hemu: Medieval king reveals true intent of Hindutva history
Farmer suicides haven't gone up in Maharashtra: Why is Modi tweaking data?
Ind vs WI: Listless batting display showed India wasn't up for the game
Twelve tasks of 'Hercules' Putin: Yes, it IS a thing in Russia
Pak's suicidal desperation: Modi-led India rising evokes LoC attacks
Lack of logic, not talent, has Windies in a spin by Mihir Fadnavis Oct 15, 2014 09:15 IST #Daniel Radcliffe #Film Review #Hollywood #Hollywood Movie #Movie Review for What if #MovieReview #Romantic Comedy #What if #Zoe Kazan When a romantic comedy panders unabashedly to its core audience, like About Time did, it’s fine. When it actually transcends the genre’s trappings and becomes much more than what it is supposed to be, it’s great. Case in point: 500 Days of Summer. But when the rom-com and everyone associated with it thinks it is cleverer than it is even though it is nothing more than hollow fluff, it’s just frustrating.
Such is the predicament of What If.
The talent attached to What If is huge – it’s got Daniel Radcliffe as a grown up, burned out by a string of bad relationships. Zoe Kazan, of the masterful Ruby Sparks, is the girl to his boy. The film has been directed by Michael Dowse, who made the terrific Goon and It’s All Gone Pete Tong. None of those three names live up to their potential thanks to the achingly clichéd and predictable script by Elan Mastai.
The story ticks off all the checkboxes to fit the ‘quirky’ indie rom-com category. Boy is a cynical but good natured bloke who’s just out of a serious relationship because his ex-significant other broke his heart. Girl is seemingly in a perfect relationship, but she thinks it’s tearing apart at the seams. Boy makes seemingly intelligent remarks about love and relationships because he’s been in a string of failures. Girl is confused because her significant other moves to another country but still wants to be in a relationship. Boy and Girl become friends and like each other but don’t know whether it’s a good idea to be more than friends. The respective friends from both sides show up on screen to offer advice. There’s some weeping and travelling around the Western world. Finally, Boy takes a flight to ‘get the girl’.
Screenshot from YouTube trailer.Will they end up together? Will they find the courage to be more than quirky? You can guess what happens in the end.
The clichés would have been fine had the characters been the least bit likable. Radcliffe and Kazan have decent chemistry and they manage a couple of fun exchanges, but not for a second does one care whether they end up together or not.
Harry Potter fans who have grown up with Radcliffe will like him in this film because he’s not just a good actor but has also shed his Potter persona finally. He already proved a thing or two in The Woman in Black and he’s here to stay for the long run. Zoe Kazan replays her role from Ruby Sparks and has little opportunity to explore any new territory. Unless you’re easily impressed by the slightest display of bittersweet romance on screen, you’ll be disappointed by the simplistic execution and wannabe style of What If.
Kazan and Radcliffe’s characters are shallow, vaguely selfish and at some points even unethical. For instance, Boy complains about his ex-girlfriend cheating on him and how his parents broke up because of infidelity just as he goes ahead and falls for a girl who is decidedly not single.
It also doesn’t help that the Girl contemplates hooking up with Boy despite him being a loser and her existing boyfriend being a successful and nice guy. It really becomes hard to root for the two of them to get together. As a result, the sugar frosted ending becomes all the more unbearable.
What If could have been great if the film had explored the ironies in the scenes it sets up, Matsai’s script doesn’t. Instead, it plays out like any other rom-com.
more in Blogs
Haider review Shahid, Tabu mesmerise in Vishal Bhardwaj's best so farBang Bang! review The remake is even more stupid than the originalBang Bang! review Hrithik, Katrina show how explosively dumb Bollywood can beEkkees Toppon Ki Salaami review A promising storyline that ends up as Facepalmrelated videosLife after Harry Potter The reality is gradually sinking inHarry Potter fans bid emotional farewell to boy wizard Most Recent Video 
Haryana polls: Will the voters allow BJP to win Karnal with an 'outsider'? 
MORE STORIES FROMMihir Fadnavis
Mumbai Film Festival 2014 Here are the films that you shouldn't miss Bang Bang! review Hrithik, Katrina show how explosively dumb Bollywood can be Raja Natwarlal review Don't get conned into watching this Emraan Hashmi film TMNT review A terribly made film that will also destroy your childhood Singham Returns review Exactly like the first, but with Kareena and more actionView more *{margin:0;padding:0}.CL{clear:both} 
After ‘Kashmir issue’, Pakistan now approaches UN to resolve ‘Arnab issue’ 
Afraid of praising anyone with name Narendra, Congress leader renames his studious son from Narendra to Rahul
Congress reinstates Tharoor as party spokesperson after he promises to spread garbage all around in city
After finding bats as source of Ebola virus, US panics and expels Batman from Gotham city
To bring down medication cost, doctor found prescribing Ghazals in place of sedatives
Bookies now confident of Pakistan winning world cup after their unpredictable 1 run loss to Australia
site indexAbout FirstpostNewsletterRSSTwitterFacebookVerticalsFront PageIndiaPoliticsWorldBusinessLifeBollywoodSportsTechPlusNew DelhiMumbaiPhotosFP ExclusivesCartoonsVideo RoomeBooksBudget 2014WeatherOthersSample Papers OnlineBusiness Technology NewsMTV IndiaOnline Shopping in IndiaThink IndiaToolsRSS FeedsNEWSLETTERGet Handpicked top news right toyour email SubscribeCopyright © 2014 Firstpost - All rights reserved Terms of use Privacy
No comments:
Post a Comment